As noted in the Final Solution Reading, “hundreds of thousands of people were involved, either directly or indirectly, in implementing the ‘Final Solution’. In your opinion, were any of these people exempt from blame? Explain your thinking. (Echoes and Reflections)
In my opinion, I think it was a little bit of the bystanders, but mostly it was the Nazis and Hitler. The top Nazis came together to make a plan because they realized they were losing the war. So they came up with the Final Solution. This plan was to exterminate Jews, Gypsies, Jehovah's Witnesses, and many other groups that were in the camps too. It was not only Jewish people, it was whoever wasn’t “pure blood”. But there were Nazis and people who knew and disagreed who didn’t do anything to help or save the people in the ghettos and camps. Anyone could be like that, teachers, the elderly, kids my age, anyone, except for people who could not have made their own decisions such as infants and the mentally impaired who could not understand what was going on. The bystanders are ALMOST as guilty as the Nazis who made and carried the idea out. Any of them could have joined the resistances or hide and help the Jewish people. But they chose to turn their faces away to the ground, and block out any and all of the horrors they knew that was going on and could have helped ended. Some people were NOT guilty at all. They were saving, helping, and hiding people. Like in 1943 and the 60 men in the Treblinka camp. They killed guards and ran to the woods to hide. And in the French Partisans resistance, there were 2,000 to 3,000 Jews who joined the resistance and helped other people escape. In the end, people who knew, didn’t like the idea, but still did nothing, in my opinion were almost as guilty as the other Nazis who carried the Final Solution.
I agree that the bystanders are also to blame besides the Nazis and Hitler. Like you said they could have done something. Even now a days when others are being bullied, people sit by the side and watch, even video tape the terrible scene. I think that's sick, and we should do something about it; but thing is, its been like 60 years and we have done nothing to stop it.
ReplyDeleteYes, I agree on what you are saying, but people have tried to stop bullying with little success. I also agree that it is cruel for people to sit and watch it happen. I think people haven't tried to stop it because the would be afraid they would become the "new" target. Also on how the people who were bystanders in the Holocaust didn't do anything because maybe they were afraid they would become the "new" target or get killed.
DeleteHave you heard/seen the phrase, "All that is required for evil to triumph is for good men to remain silent?" What lessons can you take from this?
ReplyDeleteNo a haven't until now. From this I can take is that if the good man is silent, evil will always win, but if the good man speaks, evil will fail at what it wants. What do you take from it?
Delete